Full Cast of Is It Cake Season 3: All Contestants, Judges & Hosts In New Episodes (Photos)

By Klein Felt Posted:
Is It Cake Season 3 cast, Netflix logo

Netflix's Is It Cake is back for Season 3 with a new cast of bakers ready to fool a panel of celebrity judges with their sugary creations. 

This reality cooking show, based on the viral internet meme featuring incredibly ornate cakes that look like everyday objects, sees a group of enterprising cake artists create lifelike confectionary creations to potentially win $50,000. 

Season 3 debuted on Netflix on March 29, with all eight episodes ready to be devoured. 

Every Main Contestant, Judge, & Host in Is It Cake Season 3


Mikey Day

Mikey Day Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @mikeyfuntime

Host Mikey Day returns for Season 3 after holding the mic for both Seasons 1 and 2.

Despite having no baking experience, Day was fascinated by the viral "Is It Cake?" trend, and knew he had to jump on the TV series when given the offer. 

Day is best known for his time on Saturday Night Live, where he is still a cast member after more than 10 seasons. He has also appeared in Home Sweet Home Alone, Brother Nature, and Good Burger 2.


Jay Pharoah

Jay Pharoah Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @jaypharoah

Jay Pharoah is a renowned stand-up comic and impressionist who made a name for himself by impersonating the likes of Barack Obama, Gilbert Gottfried, and Kanye West. 

Pharoah is a former Saturday Night Live cast member, appearing in six seasons from 2010 to 2015. His other previous credits include Invincible, Ride Along, and White Famous

Lauren Lapkus

Lauren Lapkus Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @laurenlapkus

Lauren Lapkus is an American actress who fans will recognize from her role as Susan Fischer in Netflix's Orange is the New Black series.

Lapkus can also be seen in HBO's Crashing, The Big Bang Theory, and The Wrong Missy

London Hughes

Is It Cake Season 3 London Hughes

Instagram: @thelondonhughes

London Hughes appears in Is It Cake Season 3 as a guest judge. She is a British actress, comedian, and television presenter. 

Hughes' previous credits include Fleabag, Sumotherhood, and Damned

Oscar Nuñez

Oscar Nuñez Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @oscarnunezla

Oscar Nuñez is a familiar face to many thanks to his work as a TV actor and comedian. 

Nuñez starred as Oscar Martinez in all nine seasons of the beloved TV sitcom The Office. His other credits include Baywatch, The Proposal, and The Lost City

Jillian Bell

Jillian Bell Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @jillianbell

Jillian Bell is an American actress, writer, and stand-up comedian. 

Bell can also be seen in 22 Jump Street, Rough Night, and Office Christmas Party

Kamie Crawford

Kamie Crawford Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @kamiecrawford

Kamie Crawford is a TV host, content producer, and former beauty queen. While she no longer competes in the beauty pageant circuit, Crawford won Miss Teen USA 2010. 

Crawford hosts MTV's Catfish: The TV Show and Are You the One?.

Dulce Sloan

Dulce Sloan Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @dulcesloan

Dulce Sloan brings her signature brand of hilarity as a celebrity judge in Is It Cake. Sloan is a well-known stand-up comedian and actress. 

Sloan's previous credits include The Daily Show, Chick Fight, and The Great North.

Chris Witaske

Chris Witaske Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @witow

Chris Witaske is a TV actor who has appeared in some major streaming hits. 

Witaske is best known for playing Chris Czajkowski in Netflix's Love and Peter in FX's The Bear

Liza Koshy

Liza Koshy Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @lizakoshy

Liza Koshy is a YouTube creator with a massive and passionate following. Koshy began her career on the short-form video platform Vine, before transitioning to YouTube to post her comedy content. 

Koshy has also appeared in several big-name Hollywood projects with credits in Transformers: Rise of the Beasts, Ruby Gillman: Teenage Kraken, and Players

Michael Ealy

Michael Ealy  Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @themichaelealy

Michael Ealy is an actor who has worked in Hollywood for nearly 25 years.

Ealy's filmography includes 2 Fast 2 Furious, Barbershop, and Think Like a Man

Heather McMahan

Heather McMahan Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @heatherkmcmahan

Heather McMahan is a writer, actress, and comedian who is also married to Dumb and Dumber star Jeff Daniels. 

McMahan is best known for her work in Love Hard, The Trap, and Zoe Ever After

Beck Bennett

Beck Bennett Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @beckbennett

Beck Bennett is yet another Saturday Night Live alum to join the Netflix series as a guest judge. Bennett is a fan-favorite actor, sketch comedian, and internet creator.

Bennett has also appeared in Dreamworks' Sing, Nimona, and Ducktales

Sam Morril

Sam Morril Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @sammorril

Sam Morril is an American stand-up comedian, actor, writer, and producer. 

Morril's previous TV and film credits include Joker, Inside Amy Schumer, and Billions

Danielle Pinnock

Danielle Pinnock Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @bodycourage

Daniell Pinnock is an actress, comedian, and writer, currently working as a main cast member on CBS's hit comedy Ghosts

Pinnock can also be seen in Young Sheldon, Tell It Like a Woman, and This Is Us

Christina P.

Christina P. Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @thechristinap

Christina P. (aka Christina Pazsitzky) is a gut-busting stand-up comedian, podcaster, writer, and TV personality.

Pazsitzky's other work includes appearances on The Midnight Gospel, Countdown, and TV: The Movie

Sherry Cola

Sherry Cola Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @shrrycola

Named one of comedy's "fresh faces" to watch by the renowned comedy club the Laugh Factory, Sherry Cola is an actress and comedian making waves in Hollywood. 

Cola starred in 2023's Joyride as well as Blue Eye Samurai and The Tiger's Apprentice

Adam Shapiro

Adam Shapiro Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @shappyshaps

Adam Shapiro is an American actor and director married to actress Katie Lowes. 

Shapiro is best known for his roles in Steve Jobs, Mank, and the Netflix series Never Have I Ever

Storm Reid

Storm Reid Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @stormreid

Storm Reid is a young actress who is turning heads in Hollywood with her varied performances in big-ticket movies and TV shows. 

Reid will be familiar to fans of HBO's The Last of Us, Euphoria, and A Wrinkle in Timer

Emma Hernan

Emma Hernan Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @emmahernan

Emma Hernan is an internet personality, influencer, and reality TV star well-known to Netflix audiences. 

Hernan is one of the primary cast members of Netflix's Selling Sunset, where she helps find buyers for some of Los Angeles's most luxurious properties. 

Justin Willman

Justin Willman Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @justinwillman

Justin Willman is a magician, comedian, and TV personality who hosts one of Netflix's other cake-based reality series, Cupcake Wars

Willman's other work includes Magic for Humans and Harley Quinn

Lana Condor

Lana Condor Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @lanacondor

Lana Condor is a 27-year-old actress and YouTube creator who fans of some of Netflix's biggest names will almost surely know. 

Condor is best known for leading the To All the Boys I've Loved Before trilogy on the streamer, and she played Jubilee in Fox's X-Men: Apocalypse

Taran Killam

Taran Killam Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @tarzannoz

Taran Killam is an actor and comedian who is married to Marvel Studios star Cobie Smulders.

Killam appeared as a cast member on Saturday Night Live from 2010-2016 and has also popped up in Why We're Killing Gunther and 12 Years a Slave

Ego Nwodim

Ego Nwodim Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @eggyboom

Ego Nwodim is an actress, comedian, and singer who is currently a member of the Saturday Night Live cast. 

Nwodim's other credits include It's a Party, Law & Order: True Crime, and K.C. Undercover

Chris Kattan

Chris Kattan Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @chriskattanofficial

Considered one of the 2000's comedy greats is actor and comedian Chris Kattan. 

Kattan appeared as a member of the Saturday Night Live cast from 1996-2003, and will be familiar to fans of A Night at the Roxbury, Undercover Brother, and The Ridiculous 6


Kristen Eagles

Kristen Eagles Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @thegirlnextdoorbakes

Kristen Eagles arrives in Is It Cake Season 3 as one of the oldest contestants in this round of the competition (42 years old). 

Eagles is a cake artist from Woodstock, Ontario, Canada who has previously appeared in Food Network's The Big Bake Season 2.

She owns a caking-making business named Cakes by K where she creates hyper-realistic pop culture-inspired cakes. 

Grace Pak

Grace Pak Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @duchessofcameron

Grace Pak is a 36-year-old New York resident, who specializes in high-end luxury cakes. 

Pak is an award-winning cake artist, having won accolades for her fine art cakes that mimic textures like porcelain, gold, and glass. 

Pak is a St. Regis NY Preferred Vendor and has appeared in other cooking and making competition shows like the Cooking Channel's Stab That Cake and Candy Land on Food Network.

Raina Washington

Raina Washington Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @thesweetstopofrva

Raina Washington is the oldest contestant on this season of Is It Cake, coming into the competition at 43 years old. 

The Richmond, Virginia native specializes in sculpted wedding cakes that look like everyday objects like spaghetti dinners, purses, and sneakers. 

Washington has also competed on Food Network's Big Time Bake

Timmy Norman

Timmy Norman Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @cakebudsjc

Timmy Norman is a 39-year-old bake shop owner from Johnson City, Tennessee. 

Norman owns the popular Cakebuds bakery and ice cream shop in Johnson City and is renowned for his slick cake and cookie-making skills that blend his sense of humor with delectable flavors. 

Norman's other TV appearances include Food Network's Big Time Bake, Food Network Challenge, and The Big Bake Champions

Jujhar Mann

Jujhar Mann Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @mannandcobakeshop

At only 23 years of age, Jujhar Mann has made a name for himself quite quickly in the baking world. 

Heralding from Surrey, British Columbia, Canada, Mann is part owner of the Mann and Co Bake Shop which specializes in custom bespoke cakes, pastries, and dessert bars. 

Mann has also shown off his confectionary creativity for TV audiences, appearing on Food Network Canada as a contestant on 2020's Great Chocolate Showdown

Henderson Gonzalez

Henderson Gonzalez Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @masterbakerfl

Henderson Gonzalez is a 34-year-old Orlando, Flordia native, coming into Is It Cake ready to compete. 

Gonzalez is an award-winning cake maker, having won the Cake Maker 2023 top prize at the American Cake Awards. 

The self-described sugar architect previously appeared in Season 3 of Spring Baking Championship: Easter. 

Julie McAllister

Julie McAllister Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @juliemcallistercakes

Creating what she calls edible art is cake-maker, Julie McAllister. 

The 35-year-old lives in Charleston, South Carolina where she creates ornate hyper-realistic cakes that look like everything from fresh fruit to a vase of flowers. 

McAllister previously appeared in Food Network's Holiday Wars.

Caitlin Taylor

Caitlin Taylor Is It Cake Season 3

Instagram: @thesculptedslice

Caitlin Taylor joins Is It Cake Season 3 looking to add to her sugar-dusted trophy cabinet. 

Taylor (30), previously won both Netflix's Sugar Rush Christmas and Discovery+'s Cakealike competition series. 

She lives in Bowie, Maryland, and has become well-known for her colorful and creative cake work.

Is It Cake Season 3 is now streaming on Netflix. 

- About The Author: Klein Felt
Klein Felt is a Senior Editor at The Direct. Joining the website back in 2020, he helped jumpstart video game content on The Direct. Klein plays a vital role as a part of the site's content team, demonstrating expertise in all things PlayStation, Marvel, and the greater entertainment industry.