1923 Season 2 Episode 3 Guide: Cast, Guest Stars & Recap of 'Wrap Thee in Terror'

Father Renaud and Marshal Kent are closing in on finding Teonna Rainwater in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3.

By Aeron Mer Eclarinal Posted:
1923 Season 2 Episode 3 cast

1923 Season 2, Episode 3 places the spotlight on Julia Schlaepfer's Alexandra Dutton as the likes of Michael Spears, C. Thomas Hawell, and Mike Mizwicki guest stars. 

The new episode of the Yellowstone prequel series, "Wrap Thee in Terror," follows Alexandra's journey to New York as she makes her way to reunite with her husband, Brandon, who has his own fair share of run-ins with the Italian mob. 

Elsewhere, Jacob Dutton continues his quest to put Zane and his family back to safety amid the ongoing storm. 

1923 Season 2, Episode 3 premiered on Paramount+ on March 9. 

1923 Season 2 Episode 3 Cast Guide: Every Main Guest Star 

Meg Hennessy - Aife 

Meg Hennessy as Aife in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Meg Hennessy

Meg Hennessy appears as Aife, the pregnant woman who mocks Alexandra Dutton in the waiting room. She ends up receiving a slap from her after her continued annoyance. 

Hennessy's other major credits include an appearance in Archive 81

Shane Jacobsen - Ticket Agent 

Shane Jacobsen as Ticket Agent in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Shane Jacobsen

Shane Jacobsen stars as the helpful ticket agent in the Grand Central Station who accommodates Alexandra and gives her tips on the best route to take to Montana.

Jacobsen is known for his roles in Panic, Social Animals, and The Brave.

Steve Luna - Deputy Marshal Clint Patterson 

Steve Luna as Deputy Marshall in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Steve Luna

Steve Luna plays Deputy Marshal Clint Patterson, the second-in-command behind US Marshal Fossett who helps with the investigation behind the deaths of the Comanche boys. 

Luna's notable credits include Shadow Boxing, UFO, and Christmas Dress.

Ron Weisberg - Dr. Kimble

Ron Weisberg as Dr. Kimble in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Ron Weisberg

Ron Weisberg makes his 1923 debut as Dr. Kimble, the second doctor who examined Alex during the immigration process.

Weisberg also starred in Killer Vacation, Day 5, and Running with the Devil

Michael Spears - Runs His Horse 

Michael Spears as Runs His Horse in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Michael Spears

Michael Spears reprises his role as Runs His Horse, Teonna Rainwater's father who goes in alone to help convince the cowboys for help with the land. 

Spears previously appeared in Into the West, You Can't Run Forever, and Reservation Dogs.

C. Thomas Howell - Anders 

C. Thomas Howell as Anders in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
C. Thomas Howell

C. Thomas Howell plays Anders, the leader of the cowboys who agrees to help Runs His Horse with their land problem.

Howell has credits in The Outsiders, The Hitcher, and Gettysburg.

Brian Letscher - Dr. Shilling 

Brian Letscher as Dr. Shilling in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Brian Letscher

Dr. Shilling (played by Brian Letscher) is the first doctor who rudely examined Alex Dutton upon her arrival in New York. 

Letscher previously appeared in Pretty Little Liars, Walker, and Grey's Anatomy

Mike Mizwicki - Walter Ridding 

Mike Mizwicki in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Mike Mizwicki

Mike Mizwicki joins the cast of 1923 Season 2, Episode 3 as Walter Ridding, the immigration officer who receives a brutally honest remark from Alexandra Dutton before eventually approving her entry to America.

Mizwicki can be seen in 9-1-1: Lone Star, Shadows in Mind, and I'll Be Around.

Andy Dispensa - Luca 

Andy Dispensa as Luca in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Andy Dispensa

Andy Dispensa returns as Luca, Spencer's newfound friend whom he saved before it is eventually revealed that he has ties to the Italian mob.

Dispensa has credits in The Chosen, NCIS: Hawaii, and Messy

Damien Leake - Marvin 

Damien Leake as Marvin in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Damien Leake

Damien Leake plays Marvin, the map seller who helps Alexandra Dutton get a cab in the busy streets of New York.

Leake is a world record-holding masters track and field athlete. As an actor, he appeared in The Great Debaters, Apocalypse Now, and Sea of Love.

Mark Daneri - Dr. Steven Miller 

Mark Daneri as Steven Miller in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Mark Daneri

Mark Daneri makes a prominent appearance as Dr. Steven Miller, the Duttons' trusted doctor who checks in on Elizabeth Strafford and Zane upon his arrival to the ranch.

Daneri also starred in American Crime, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and Magic City.

Dougie Hall - Two Spears

Dougie Hall as Two Spears in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Dougie Hall

Dougie Hall plays Two Spears, US Marshal Mamie Fossett's trusted translator who is a member of the Comanche tribe. 

1923 is Hall's first major acting credit.

Here are the main actors who appeared in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3: 

  • Harrison Ford - Jacob Dutton
  • Helen Mirren - Cara Dutton
  • Brandon Sklenar - Spencer Dutton
  • Darren Mann - Jack Dutton
  • Michelle Randolph - Elizabeth Strafford 
  • Sebastian Roche - Father Renaud 
  • Jamie McShane - Marshal Kent
  • Brian Geraghty - Zane Davis 
  • Cooper Taylor - Spade
  • Julia Schlaepfer - Alexandra Dutton 
  • Joy Osmanski - Alice Davis
  • Jennifer Carpenter - US Marshal Mamie Fossett 

Meanwhile, here are the other minor actors who appeared in the new episode:

  • Kelly Dealyn - Nurse (Exam Room)  
  • Nancy L. Gray - Nurse 
  • Lauren Martinez - Pregnant Woman
  • Matt Blackwell - Immigration Officer
  • Caleb Martin - Dennis 
  • Danielle Vasinova - Ata Waipa 
  • Charlie Ferguson - Cook 
  • Kareem Badr - Cab Driver 
  • Luke Marinkovich - Alabaster Man
  • Jason Kyle Johnson - Army Sergeant 
  • Jon Michael Davis - Doctor # 1 
  • Josh Cole - Second Mate 

1923 Season 2 Episode 3 Plot Recap 

Cara Dutton Doesn't Play Around

Helen Mirren as Cara Dutton in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Helen Mirren

Following the cliffhanger ending of 1923 Season 2, Episode 2 (read more about its cast here) where Cara Dutton comes face to face with a wolf, "Wrap Thee in Terror" reveals that she prevailed, ultimately nailing the dead animal in a cross to serve as a warning to other wolves that the Yellowstone ranch is off limits. 

After the nurse from the previous episode seemingly died off-screen due to the wolf, Cara helps the doctor and Spade to put some sense into Elizabeth, who is still grappling with the fact that she needs to be injected with a rabies shot 12 times in 10 days. 

Elsewhere, Jacob Dutton and his troops manage to survive the harsh snow conditions, but the fight is far from over as they need to head back while tending to a still-injured Zane. 

They arrive at the ranch just in time before Dr. Miller is about to leave. The good doctor checks on Zane, ultimately telling him that he has been diagnosed with subdural hematoma and the blood needs to be drained so he can be okay (read more about Zane's journey in 1923 Season 2).

The problem is Dr. Miller has no anesthesia to put Zane to sleep while he literally drills into his skull. 

Meanwhile, Jack Dutton reunites with his wife Elizabeth who is now packing her things since she is determined to move back to Boston. It turns out that she has had enough of the ranch life, but she needs to finish her injection shots first before finally leaving. 

Alexandra's Journey Continues

Julia Schlaepfer as Alexandra Dutton in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Julia Schlaepfer

After a perilous journey in the Atlantic seas, Alexandra of Sussex (or should I say, Alexandra Dutton) has finally made it to New York. However, there are setbacks on her arrival. 

After dealing with rude doctors and immigration officers, she is almost sent home because of a policy about pregnant women being sent back to their home country because they can't work. 

In the final interview, she gives a brutally honest response about freedom and how women are treated right before they enter America, noting, "I would say this is the least free I have ever felt in my life. If you wish to deny me entry, deny it, but deny it with some courtesy."

Thankfully, her passionate speech gives her stamp of approval to enter New York before eventually finding her way to Grand Central Station where she buys her train ticket to Montana. 

While she has smooth sailing after entering the United States, Alexandra's fate is uncertain after a shady man follows her in the bathroom of the train. 

The Pursuit for Teonna Rainwater 

Michael Spears as Runs His Horse in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Michael Spears

While Teonna Rainwater doesn't appear on-screen, the character's storyline this episode is anchored by those pursuing her and her father, Runs His Horse. 

In 1923 Season 2, Episode 2, Runs His Horse leaves Teonna and Pete Plenty Clouds to find a group of cowboys whom he deems as ranch owners to ask permission if they can stay on their land for the meantime. 

Runs His Horse ends up finding the said cowboys and they agree with the native's request as long as he helps them run cattle right through where Teonna and Pete's camp is. 

Meanwhile, US Marshal Mamie Fossett comes across a group of Comanche boys killed by the ruthless Father Renaud and Marshal Kent in the previous episode. 

Fossett asks her translator (who is also a loyal enforcer) to tell the members of the tribe seeking revenge to stand down and leave it to her to deal with this fiasco. 

Speaking of Renaud and Kent, the pair have already reached the Texas border where they talk about the importance of cowboys in the ever-changing landscape of the Midwest. 

Spencer & Luca Have Their Own Set of Troubles

Brandon Sklenar as Spencer Dutton in 1923 Season 2, Episode 3
Brandon Sklenar

After a run-in with the Italian mob, Spencer and Luca are on a drive from Galveston to Fort Worth to deliver illegal booze in exchange for their freedom, but it appears that Spencer is not on board with the idea anymore due to a run-in with the border guards. 

Luca tries to threaten him by pulling a gun on him, but Spencer quickly disarms him and asks to join him and look the other way. 

However, family is at the top of Luca's priority list and he still engages in a shootout with the border guards which tragically kills him in the end.


New episodes of 1923 Season 2 premiere every Sunday on Paramount+ at midnight PT (read more about its official release schedule here). 

- In This Article: Yellowstone
Release Date
November 10, 2023
Platform
Actors
Kelly Reilly
Kevin Costner
Luke Grimes
Genres
- About The Author: Aeron Mer Eclarinal
Aeron is a news/features writer and Content Lead for The Direct who has been working for the site since March 2020. From writing about the inter-connectivity of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to having an extended knowledge about DC TV's Arrowverse, Aeron's expertise has since expanded into the realm of reality TV, K-drama, animated, and live-action shows from Netflix,  Disney+, Prime Video, MGM+, Peacock, Paramount+, and Max. When he isn't writing and watching all things MCU, Aeron is heavily invested with the NBA (go Celtics!) and occasionally watches thrilling matches in the WWE.