Till Murder Do Us Part Netflix 2023 Cast: Meet the Real People In the Series

Netflix's Till Murder Do Us Part has an interesting cast of interviewees that help unpack the case.

By Aeron Mer Eclarinal Posted:
Till Murder Do Us Part, Netflix logo

Netflix's 2023 docu-series, Till Murder Do Us Part, recounts the killings of Derek and Nancy Haysom by including a series of interviews with a cast of real people. 

The four-part docu-series revolves around the unpacking of how a wealthy couple was murdered in Virginia in 1985. It also focuses on how the suspects, Elizabeth Haysom, and her boyfriend, Jens Soehring, betrayed each other during the trial. 

Till Murder Do Us Part made its debut on Netflix on November 1. 

Every Main Interviewee in 2023's Till Murder Do Us Part 

Jens Soering

Suspect

Jens Soering
Jens Soering

Jens Soering is one of the suspects in the Derek and Nancy Haysom killings in 1985. He is the boyfriend of the couple's daughter, Elizabeth Haysom. 

Jens is the son of a German diplomat. During the murder trial, he turned on Elizabeth by admitting that he was the one who killed her parents.

Buzz McFaden 

Road Deputy, Bedford County

Buzz McFaden
Buzz McFaden

As a road deputy of Bedford County, Buzz McFaden was one of the early responders when the Haysoms were murdered. 

He was assigned to be the crime scene security officer during the ordeal. Buzz pointed out that the couple were not simply killed, noting that "there was a lot of hatred [there]."

Tammy Martin 

Former Sheriff’s Deputy, Bedford County

Tammy Martin
Tammy Martin

Tammy Martin was a sheriff's deputy of Bedford County when the murders happened in 1985. 

She explained that Bedford County was "not the same" after the murders. 

Jeff Taylor

News Anchor

Jeff Taylor
Jeff Taylor

Working as the managing editor and anchor of Channel 13, Jeff Taylor was the one who spearheaded the broadcast of the Haysoms murders in 1985.

He is also one of the friends and neighbors of Derek and Nancy Haysom. 

Louis Benedict 

Nancy Haysom’s Brother

Louis Benedict
Louis Benedict 

Louis Benedict is Nancy Haysom's brother who was devastated by her death. 

He also revealed that Nancy wanted to be the leader of the Lynchburg Society before her demise. 

Kay Benedict

Nancy Haysom’s Sister-in-Law

Kay Benedict
Kay Benedict

Kay Benedict is Louis' wife and Nancy's sister-in-law. 

Kay revealed that Elizabeth, the suspect and the couple's youngest daughter, was actually the one who organized her parent's funeral. 

Chuck Reid 

Lead Investigator, Bedford County Sheriff’s Office

Chuck Reid
Chuck Reid 

Chuck Reid is one of the lead investigators of the Bedford County Sheriff's Office who took on the case in 1985. 

Having worked for law enforcement for 30 years, he admitted that the Haysom murders were "probably the worst" he ever saw. 

Ricky Gardner 

Lead Investigator, Bedford County Sheriff’s Office

Ricky Gardner
Ricky Gardner

Ricky Gardner is another lead investigator who worked on the case and was also Chuck Reid's partner in 1985. 

Ricky was assigned to ask the neighbors if they'd seen anything unusual with the Haysoms during the day of the murder. 

Ken Beever

Detective Sergeant Metropolitan Police

Ken Beever
Ken Beever

Ken Beever was a detective sergeant of the Metropolitan Police in Richmond, London in 1986. 

He was the one who ordered the store detective to arrest Elizabeth and Jens while they were purchasing goods at the market.  

They were the ones who discovered the couple's mysterious belongings, which included fake identifications, wigs, and all sorts of clothes. 

Amy Lemley 

UVA Alumna & Local Reporter

Amy Lemley
Amy Lemley 

Amy Lemley is a local reporter and an Echols scholar who knew about Jens Soering and Elizabeth Haysom's relationship and was a friend of the couple. 

Amy talked about how "everybody was surprised that these two ended up together."

Phyllis Workman

Elizabeth’s Cousin

Phyllis Workman
Phyllis Workman

Phyllis Workman is the only family member of Elizabeth in Lynchburg who was close to her. 

She revealed that Elizabeth told her about "the anger that Jens felt toward her parents" because they wanted the couple to break up. 

Hanns Feigen

Former Attorney for Jens Soering

Hanns Feigen
Hanns Feigen 

Hanns Feigen revealed that it was Jens' father who approached him to represent his son during the murder trial. 

Hanns revealed that the goal was to try to get Jens extradited to Germany and avoid the death penalty.

Rachel Ryan

Investigative Journalist

Rachel Ryan
Rachel Ryan

Rachel Ryan is an investigative journalist who explored everything about the Haysoms' death. 

She discussed how Elizabeth cut things off with Jens and how it greatly impacted the latter. 

Courteney Stuart 

Investigative Journalist

Courteney Stuart
Courteney Stuart 

Another investigative journalist who worked on the case is Courteney Stuart. 

Courteney talked about the reactions to seeing Jens back in the United States. She also did some reporting about this case, with her describing then that it was "just a total media circus."

Carlos Santos

Crime Reporter

Carlos Santos
Carlos Santos

Carlos Santos is a crime reporter who talked about the work of Prosecutor James Updike and how the case impacted his career. 

Santos is a proven veteran since he covered over 40 murder trials in Virginia. 

Sandy Hausman 

Radio Reporter

Sandy Hausman
Sandy Hausman 

Sandy Hausman is a radio reporter who was able to talk to Jens after being sent to prison. Sandy described Jens as an "intriguing character."

Chip Harding 

Former Sheriff

Chip Harding
Chip Harding 

As a former investigator who has over 30 years of experience, Chip Harding was the one who reviewed Jens' case, and said, "Whoa! This is nothing like what was represented in the media."

Chip believed that Jens had been labeled a murderer because "a jury heard a set of what they thought were facts, but actually weren't accurate."

John Grisham

Bestselling Author & Former Lawyer

John Grisham
John Grisham

John Grisham was a lawyer who is now a bestselling author and spent over 500 hours investigating Jens' case with Chip Harding because they believed that "this guy is innocent."

Dr. Stuart Hamilton

Pathologist

Dr. Stuart Hamilton
Dr. Stuart Hamilton

Dr. Stuart Hamilton is a pathologist who investigated how Jens allegedly slit Derek Haysom's throat. 

Stuart noted that Jens' confession "doesn't seem to fit the pathology," pointing out that there were multiple slices that were severe enough to damage Derek's windpipe. 

Dr. Andy Griffiths 

Police Interview Expert

Dr. Andy Griffiths
Dr. Andy Griffiths 

Working as a police interview expert, Dr. Andy Griffiths analyzed how it was evident that something was wrong when the police questioned Jens at the Richmond police station in Southwest London. 

Andy noted that the interview would've included all the crime scene exhibits, witness statements, pieces of forensic information, and breaks to verify the information. 

Chris Fabricant

Forensics Science Expert

Chris Fabricant
Chris Fabricant

As a forensics science expert, Chris Fabricant discussed Jens' sock size and how it factored in during the investigation. 

Andrew Hammel

Author & Former Lawyer

Andrew Hammel
Andrew Hammel

Andrew Hammel, a former lawyer and an author, talked about Jens' failed attempts to prove his innocence at the appeal courts and how the convicted felon managed to write a book named Mortal Thoughts that chronicled his real side of the story.

Dr. Sarah Reel 

Forensic Podiatrist

Dr. Sarah Reel
Dr. Sarah Reel

Dr. Sarah Reel is a forensic podiatrist who was involved with Jens' and Elizabeth's footprint examination. Sarah pointed out that, statistically, there is no difference "between a bare footprint and a socked footprint."

The doctor suggested that Jens' reference footprint matched closely with the crime scene footprint. 


In the four-part docu-series, here are the actors who starred in the recreation of the murder: 

  • Camillo Guthmann - Jens Soering
  • Luise Ehl - Elizabeth Haysom
  • Dominic Reisner - Terry Wright
  • Bradley Hengerer - Terry Wright (US)
  • Leif Eisenberg - Ricky Gardner
  • Brendan Lynch - Ricky Gardner (US)
  • Serhii Zabairachnyi - Ken Beever
  • Ray Manfredi - Ken Beever (US)
  • Maik Kubbillun - Chuck Reid
  • Yvonne Blaschke - Girlfriend Elizabeth Haysom
  • John Stone - Robert Lewis Albright
  • Danny Aus Den Birken - William L. Shifflett
  • Lelia Yvetta - Elizabeth Haysom (voice)
  • Flynn Shank - Jens Soering (voice)

Till Murder Do Us Part is now streaming on Netflix.

- About The Author: Aeron Mer Eclarinal
Aeron is a news/features writer and Content Lead for The Direct who has been working for the site since March 2020. From writing about the inter-connectivity of the Marvel Cinematic Universe to having an extended knowledge about DC TV's Arrowverse, Aeron's expertise has since expanded into the realm of reality TV, K-drama, animated, and live-action shows from Netflix,  Disney+, Prime Video, MGM+, Peacock, Paramount+, and Max. When he isn't writing and watching all things MCU, Aeron is heavily invested with the NBA (go Celtics!) and occasionally watches thrilling matches in the WWE.